Commentary: In Indonesia and more countries, social media and Big Tobacco are hooking a whole new generation of smokers

Ad agency have actually skillfully leveraged social networks to keep tobacco marketing under the guideline radar, University of Southern California’s Robert Kozinets mentions.

A man passes a tobacco shop in Shanghai on World No Tobacco Day on May 31, 2013

A guy passes a tobacco store in Shanghai on World No Tobacco Day on May31 (Picture: AFP/Peter Parks).

CALIFORNIA: Big Tobacco is progressively utilizing social networks to discover brand-new methods to hook youths on smoking cigarettes, preventing years of laws limiting the marketing of conventional cigarettes to minors.

In significant cities all over the world such as Rio de Janeiro, Cairo, Jakarta and Milan, tobacco business have actually been holding elegant occasions with names like “K_Player” and “RedMoveNow” that were developed to get in touch with youths.

Frequently including alcohol, live music and appealing hosts, these extravagant occasions extra no expenditure as they look for discover brand-new purchasers for their tobacco items.

The issue? Those party-goers are thoroughly targeting young influencers, who are motivated to share images of their attractive tobacco-sponsored experiences with pals and fans on social networks utilizing appealing hashtags like #iamonthemove, #decideyourflow and #mydaynow.

Although the influencers are over 18, their social networks fans can be much more youthful.

Composite screen grabs of Instagram posts by social media influencers.

Composite screen grabs of Instagram posts by social networks influencers. (Picture: Instagram).

This exploitation of social networks’s natural reach is among the findings from an international research study job I have actually been dealing with given that 2016 with more than a lots various scholars.

The anti-smoking advocacy group Tobacco-Free Children discovered a great deal of images of youths with cigarettes showing up in their online scans of worldwide social networks and asked me to check out it.

READ: Shady techniques in influencer projects make social networks the brand-new frontier for stubbing out smoking cigarettes, a commentary

My own research study concentrates on how to carefully investigate online culture utilizing natural observational strategies, something that this research study absolutely needed.

My group’s job was to keep an eye on, report upon and evaluate the programs behind the hashtagged social networks posts of youths smoking cigarettes. What we discovered tobacco business’s existing marketing shocked us.


Tobacco business have actually constantly had a flair for discovering imaginative methods to skirt policies meant to suppress marketing to youths.

In 1971, the United States Congress prohibited tobacco advertisements from tv and radio. In reaction, business invested greatly in outside marketing and publications.

In 1997, the Tobacco Master Settlement Arrangement prohibited tobacco on outside and signboard advertisements. In reaction, tobacco loan streamed into sponsorships of sports, music and other occasions.

These kind of occasion sponsorships were prohibited, with some exceptions, in 2010, at the exact same time larger constraints on youth marketing were likewise presented.

High school students look at a mock up of plain cigarette packaging in Ottawa

High school trainees take a look at a mock up of plain cigarette product packaging prior to the start of a press conference in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, Might 31,2016 (Picture: REUTERS/Chris Wattie).

READ: Tobacco business play mind video games to make stopping harder in the UK, a commentary

No matter the medium, the messaging was typically the exact same: Discover methods to reach brand-new and young prospective cigarette smokers. As files from the Tradition Tobacco Files Library expose, tobacco executives have actually long thought that the ongoing survival and success of their business depends upon something: Persuading youths to purchase their items.

In 2005, the World Health Organisation prohibited tobacco marketing in 168 signatory nations. By 2010, the United States had actually closed a great deal of Huge Tobacco’s preferred marketing and tobacco loopholes.

With traditional media mainly off-limits, what was Huge Tobacco to do? Like the Marlboro Guy, the uncontrolled Wild West of social networks rode to the rescue.


Social network fits Huge Tobacco’s marketing requires to a tee.

A minimum of 88 percent of American youth state they utilize social networks apps like Facebook and Instagram frequently, and the innovations are infamously hard to manage.

With Tobacco-Free Children’ financial backing, I put together a growing group of scientists to examine. Our work is continuous.

My group gathered a variety of social networks information and likewise carried out interviews with a series of tobacco brand name ambassadors, celebration participants, influencers and market experts from all over the world.

What we discovered was an astoundingly efficient usage of social networks by a series of various tobacco business to get in touch with the next generation of prospective cigarette smokers.

file photo of smoking

Submit image of an individual smoking cigarettes. ( Picture: AFP).

While tobacco business took care to comply with the letter of the law– the influencers associated with these posts were all of legal smoking cigarettes age in their nations– social networks has a public setting that makes it a reliable and mainly uncontrolled kind of broadcast.

Lawfully, anybody age 13 or over can have an Instagram or Facebook account.

Our “netnography”– a kind of qualitative social networks query that concentrates on cultural contexts, social structures and much deeper significances– just took a look at public posts, images that any 13- year-old with an account might see.


Our examination revealed a series of marketing activities and a web of public relations and ad agency that skillfully leveraged the strengths of social networks to keep tobacco marketing under the radar of existing guideline.

We discovered tobacco business in nations such as Indonesia and the Philippines hiring “nano-influencers” of simply 2,000 to 3,000 fans on Facebook and Instagram and motivating them to publish about their tobacco-sponsored experiences.

In Indonesia, we discovered brand name ambassador training school that lasted 2 complete weeks and were run by the domestic tobacco business Gudang Garam. At these camps, young nano-influencers were paid generous charges, taught about cigarette brand names images and after that offered lessons about how to much better keep their social networks feeds.

Public relations firms in Uruguay taught their influencers how to take images of cigarette plans in manner ins which finest emphasized their brand names, using ideas on lighting, hashtags and the very best time to publish them for optimum effect.

Gudang Garam cigarette packs displaying "health warning" images are seen at a stall in Ja

Gudang Garam cigarette loads showing “health caution” images are seen at a stall in Jakarta, Indonesia, May 31,2017 Image taken May 31,2017 REUTERS/Beawiharta.

READ: Youth smoking cigarettes is an issue, so is youth vaping, a commentary

Some business utilized Facebook pages to hire youths to attend their celebrations. After addressing a couple of concerns on the Facebook page, for instance, responders were registered in a newsletter leading to invites to cool pop-up “celebrations and edgier occasions”.

At those celebrations, youths were welcomed by appealing attendants who used them cigarettes and motivated them to present with flooring styles imitated cigarette brand name logo designs.

After snapping photos, they were motivated to publish them on their social networks feed utilizing the celebration’s decisiveness and action-oriented hashtags. The outcome was undoubtedly a brand-new kind of cigarette promo.

These activities plainly break the spirit of the existing arrangements not to indirectly market to youths. You can call it stealth, undercover or guerrilla marketing if you want. Whatever its name, this is 21 st-century cigarette marketing that reaches countless youths all over the world.


Our research study has not just assisted shine a light on Huge Tobacco’s uncontrolled usage of social networks, it has actually likewise notified a current petition to the United States Federal Trade Commission requesting it to examine and impose these unique types of cigarette marketing.

READ: UK’s tobacco plain product packaging uses lessons for nations, a commentary

Indonesia youth smoking

Indonesian youth smoke clove cigarettes in Jakarta on April 7,2012 (Picture: AFP/Oscar Siagian).

Although it may be hard for federal governments to continue top of media in these quickly altering times, they should do so if they want to avoid worldwide smoking cigarettes rates and their ensuing health issue from increasing as soon as again.

Certainly, with management modification in the United States Fda, brand-new and tighter policies on tobacco and vaping in the United States are currently being cast into doubt.

READ: Flavoured e-cigarettes sustaining a hazardous boost in tobacco usage, a commentary

Social network offer an extraordinary advance in interactions that democratise interactions in extraordinary methods.

Nevertheless, that openness is simple to make use of by online marketers with suspicious intentions.

Robert V Kozinets is the Jayne and Hans Hufschmid Chair in Strategic Public Relations and Organisation Interaction at University of Southern California’s Annenberg School for Interaction and Journalism. This commentary initially appeared on The Discussion.


Leave a Comment

Translate »